Identifying Assumptions & Drawing Conclusions
Critical reasoning items present a short statement or policy situation and ask you to identify an unstated assumption or a necessary conclusion.
CSC Exam Tip: Memorize the Negation Test for Assumptions! Negate (put "NOT") into an answer choice: if negating the choice destroys or invalidates the author's argument, then that choice IS a necessary assumption!
1. Anatomy of an Argument
Every critical reasoning item has three parts:
- 1Premise (Evidence): Explicitly stated facts ("Since the agency adopted online appointment scheduling, daily walk-in congestion dropped by 60%.").
- 2Conclusion (Claim): What the speaker tries to prove ("Therefore, all regional branches should adopt online scheduling to eliminate long lines.").
- 3Assumption (Unstated Bridge): The hidden premise connecting the Evidence to the Conclusion ("Regional branches experience walk-in patterns and internet accessibility comparable to the main office.").
2. How to Solve "Identifying Assumptions" Items
- An assumption is unstated but taken for granted by the speaker.
- Step 1: Spot the gap (new term or leap) between the Premise and the Conclusion.
- Statement: "Applicant Reyes graduated with honors; therefore, she will be an exemplary division supervisor."
- Hidden Assumption: Academic honors translate into supervisory competence (or people who graduate with honors make exemplary supervisors).
- Step 2 (Negation Test): Test "Academic honors do NOT indicate supervisory competence." → The conclusion immediately collapses! Confirmed!
3. How to Solve "Drawing Conclusions" Items
Unlike assumptions (which support the argument), a valid conclusion must follow strictly from the given facts alone:
- Treat every premise in the question as 100% true, even if unusual, and banish all outside assumptions!
- Watch Quantifier Strength:
- "Most employees commute by bus" allows you to conclude "At least some employees commute by bus" or "Not all employees drive private cars"—it does NOT prove "No employee takes the train" or "Bus fares are cheap."
- Correlation vs. Causation Trap: If two events happen together, do not conclude one caused the other unless the text establishes causation.